Is the Jeep Wrangler a Reliable Car?

October 21, 2022

As the successor to the Willys CJs, the Jeep Wrangler is just as iconic as its roots. This funky-looking American SUV is one of the most popular and capable off-roaders ever made. And the fact that it’s a pop culture darling makes it unsurprising you crave to own one.

However, if you're planning to buy a Jeep Wrangler, you might question its reliability and which model year to go for. Those are the mysteries I’ll try to solve here, as I'll reveal how reliable Jeep Wranglers are, which model years you should target and avoid, and what common problems these cool SUVs have. Also, keep reading to know how a Jeep Wrangler service manual can help you with any repair, even when you are stranded in the middle of nowhere.

Let's go!

Good Vs. Bad Years

The Jeep Wrangler has been around since 1986 and is now in its fourth generation. Each gen offered several body styles, engine choices, trim packages, and many customization options. 

The SUV has also undergone a series of yearly updates, so it's unfair to assume all model years have the same reliability. Not all Wrangler years are created equal; some are more/less reliable than others.

Hence, the wise move is to know which model years you should seek and avoid before starting shopping for a Wrangler. Here's my summary:

First Generation: YJ (1986-1995)

Despite being the first Wrangler breed, the YJs were overall pretty reliable. However, the best model years to get, dependability-wise, are the younger ones from 1992-1995, preferably those with AMC's fuel-injected 4.0-liter inline-6 engine, which was more reliable and economical. Additionally, the YJs of this batch also got galvanized body panels resistant to corrosion.

Meanwhile, according to the NHTSA, some of the worst Wrangler YJs are the ones produced between 1987 and 1991. Common problems include engine start difficulty, failing transmissions, failing fuel pumps, leaking engine seals, and electrical issues causing the radio, heater, and lights to stop working. These Wrangler model years also don’t have any rust protection from the factory, something to keep in mind if you live in the northeast.

Second Generation: TJ (1997-2006)

The TJ was favored by many since Jeep brought back the classic round headlamps and adopted a more comfortable coil spring suspension. Yet, its reliability wasn't as solid as the previous generation. Particularly, the most fragile ones were born between 1997 and 2002, on which NHTSA received over 300 complaints per model year. Some of their common problems include a failing instrument cluster, faulty fuel filler, and cracked manifold on the AMC 4.0-liter inline-6 unit.

Therefore, from a reliability point of view, I’d recommend going for the 2003-2006 models, especially those adopting the newer Chrysler 2.4-liter inline-4 that's commonly less troublesome than the 6-cylinder unit. Still, note that these younger TJs were bound to the fuel filler problem and death wobble (a condition of a wobbly steering wheel happening at high speed, caused by poorly/incorrectly installed suspension parts and the Wrangler’s solid front axle).

But the second-gen Wrangler is also quite easy to maintain and repair, even if you are a novice DIYer. All you need is a set of tools and a good repair manual, where you’ll find detailed information on how to conduct every repair procedure. It might sound scary, but trust me — I’m a novice mechanic myself, yet I already worked on the engine and suspension using my trusty 2004 Jeep Wrangler service manual. It’s so easy — just follow the instructions and detailed illustrations, and you’ll finish in no time!

Need a repair manual for your Jeep and are not sure where to start? Head to eManualOnline right away — they offer repair manuals for pretty much any Wrangler model and at a fraction of the price of a single visit to the repair shop.

Third Generation: JK (2006-2018)

There's a long list of JK's improvements over the TJ. It was bigger, practical, daily-driveable, and arguably better looking. But despite all the enhancements, the JK generation does seem to host some of the most unreliable and financially hurting Wrangler model years.

For instance, the 2007 and 2008 models had as many as 10 recalls each, with issues such as the classic death wobble, brake system failure, and total engine failure. The 2008MY even had additional problems like TIPM failure and excessive engine oil consumption.

But when it comes to the most unreliable Jeep Wrangler, many agreed the 2012 model year takes the cake. It was concerned by 10 recalls and prone to costly mechanical failures easily unnoticed when buying used, such as massive oil leaks, TIPM failure, misfiring cylinder head, intermittent engine stall, faulty heater, and water leaks from the A-pillar.

Hence, if you own this model year and can relate to those major issues, I recommend getting a service manual for the 2012 Jeep Wrangler, which will help you nail some of those fixes yourself and save you from expensive repair bills. Otherwise, do yourself a favor and avoid this model year altogether.

That said, if you're still interested in getting a used JK Wrangler, aim for the 2015-2018 models, which seemed to have solved some of those issues. But at this price point, you could also consider the JL, especially if you want to avoid the death wobble issue completely.

Fourth Generation: JL (2018-present)

The JL is arguably the most reliable Wrangler generation, proving Jeep has learned much from the previous models. Sure, there were some recalls regarding steering issues with the 2018 batch, but the manufacturer quickly resolved them for the 2019 model onwards. Since then, the Wrangler's complaint mailbox has been relatively quiet, and it finally received a properly good reliability rating of 4/5 stars from both US News and the NHTSA.

However, remember that even this latest Wrangler gen isn't completely trouble-free. Some have experienced problems revolving around the steering and drivetrain. Still, if your JL Wrangler is covered by the manufacturer warranty (which is mostly the case), you can usually get it fixed at a nearby Jeep dealer for free.

The Truth About Jeep Wrangler's Reliability Score

Sure, there have been some harsh criticisms and complaints about the Jeep Wrangler's poor reliability, leading to sites like Consumer Reports and JD Power being somewhat brutal on their reliability ratings.

But despite all that, it seemed like people were still buying it anyway. The Wrangler's sales figure has been brisk and kept increasing over the last quarter century. That applies particularly in the US, where Jeep sold 200,000 Wranglers annually over the previous four years.

The truth is, regardless of the reliability rating, the Wrangler is still an icon representing a lifestyle. It's one of those unique vehicles that hold sentimental value, and people tend to involve more emotions when deciding on the purchase. You don't even have to be an off-road enthusiast to want one.

To its passionate owners, the Wrangler's poor reliability is just a small price to drive a stylish truck with such a legendary status. At the end of the day, you can always buy a Toyota 4Runner if you want a more reliable SUV!

So, Is The Jeep Wrangler Reliable?

Well, it depends. We've learned that not all Wranglers have been created equal for the past 36 years of production. Hence, determining a Wrangler's reliability would have to factor in many variables like the specific generation and model year, engine and transmission options, and even the trim package it adopts.

Nevertheless, judging by the trend, the most reliable Wranglers are often produced during the last few years before the generation is discontinued. But regardless, if you ever bought this iconic truck, be sure also to get its Jeep Wrangler repair manual to help you overcome those possible breaking-down moments!

Leave a Comment: